Difference between revisions of "PRE2016 3 Groep3"

From Control Systems Technology Group
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 152: Line 152:
= Week 8 =
= Week 8 =
= Sources =
= Sources =
[1] Smith, O. (2016). No more commuter misery? Trains fight leaves with lasers. Retrieved from [http://www.thememo.com/2016/09/12/train-leaves-leaf-zapping-trains-rail-safety-and-standards-board-are-arming-up-with-microwaves-and-lasers/]  
[1] Smith, O. (2016). No more commuter misery? Trains fight leaves with lasers. Retrieved from [http://www.thememo.com/2016/09/12/train-leaves-leaf-zapping-trains-rail-safety-and-standards-board-are-arming-up-with-microwaves-and-lasers/ The Memo]  

[2] Sorokanich, B. (2016). This Hand-Held Laser Makes Rust Literally Evaporate. Retrieved from [http://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/classic-cars/videos/a30597/best-rust-remover-laser/]  
[2] Sorokanich, B. (2016). This Hand-Held Laser Makes Rust Literally Evaporate. Retrieved from [http://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/classic-cars/videos/a30597/best-rust-remover-laser/ Road and Track]  

[3] P-Laser (2017). Laser cleaning applications. Retrieved from [http://www.p-laser.com/applications_detail.aspx?AGUID=1f846979-8fea-4745-bcea-663800c027e5&LGUID=8565a502-c109-43ef-b1a1-dfba5f3edbf6]  
[3] P-Laser (2017). Laser cleaning applications. Retrieved from [http://www.p-laser.com/applications_detail.aspx?AGUID=1f846979-8fea-4745-bcea-663800c027e5&LGUID=8565a502-c109-43ef-b1a1-dfba5f3edbf6 P-Laser]  

[4] Vega, R. et all (1990). Laser ice removal system. Retrieved from [https://www.google.com/patents/US4900891]
[4] Vega, R. et all (1990). Laser ice removal system. Retrieved from [https://www.google.com/patents/US4900891 Google Patents]

[5] Statistics about railway disturbances in the Netherlands. Retrieved from [https://www.rijdendetreinen.nl/statistieken]
[5] Statistics about railway disturbances in the Netherlands. Retrieved from [https://www.rijdendetreinen.nl/statistieken Rijdende Treinen]

[6] Different kind of disturbances around railway tracks. Retrieved from: [https://www.prorail.nl/reizigers/storingen-op-het-spoor]
[6] Different kind of disturbances around railway tracks. Retrieved from: [https://www.prorail.nl/reizigers/storingen-op-het-spoor ProRail]

[7] Article about leavs on the railway tracks. Retrieved from : [http://www.metronieuws.nl/nieuws/binnenland/2016/11/die-rot-blaadjes-op-het-spoor-waarom-doen-ze-niets]
[7] Article about leavs on the railway tracks. Retrieved from : [http://www.metronieuws.nl/nieuws/binnenland/2016/11/die-rot-blaadjes-op-het-spoor-waarom-doen-ze-niets Metronieuws]

[8] Paper geometry railways. Retrieved from: [http://crema.di.unimi.it/~fscotti/ita/pdf/Scotti02.pdf]
[8] Paper geometry railways. Retrieved from: [http://crema.di.unimi.it/~fscotti/ita/pdf/Scotti02.pdf]
Line 170: Line 170:
[9] Paper wear railways. Retriever from: [https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/pdfs/US6218961.pdf]
[9] Paper wear railways. Retriever from: [https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/pdfs/US6218961.pdf]

[10] Drones with infrared cameras 1. Retrieved from: [https://www.prorail.nl/nieuws/proef-met-drones-controleren-wisselverwarming-met-infraroodcamera-s]
[10] Drones with infrared cameras 1. Retrieved from: [https://www.prorail.nl/nieuws/proef-met-drones-controleren-wisselverwarming-met-infraroodcamera-s ProRail]

[11] Drones with infrared cameras 2. Retrieved from: [https://tweakers.net/nieuws/86694/prorail-zet-drones-in-om-verwarming-van-wissels-te-controleren.html]
[11] Drones with infrared cameras 2. Retrieved from: [https://tweakers.net/nieuws/86694/prorail-zet-drones-in-om-verwarming-van-wissels-te-controleren.html Tweakers]

[12] Railway monitor. Retrieved from: [http://www.etsspoor.nl/producten/meetapparatuur/railmonitor/]
[12] Railway monitor. Retrieved from: [http://www.etsspoor.nl/producten/meetapparatuur/railmonitor/ ETS Spoor]

[13] Railway switches inspection robot Felix. Retrieved from: [http://research.loccioni.com/en/robotics/felix/]
[13] Railway switches inspection robot Felix. Retrieved from: [http://research.loccioni.com/en/robotics/felix/ Loccioni]

[14] Jaarverslag 2015, ProRail
[14] Jaarverslag 2015, ProRail. Retrieved from: [http://www.jaarverslagprorail.nl/FbContent.ashx/pub_1000/Downloads/ProRail-jaarverslag-2015.pdf ProRail]

Revision as of 23:34, 19 February 2017

Group 3: Railway Maintenance Robots

  • 0902228 | Lindsey van der Aalst
  • 0938349 | Thomas Bastiaansen
  • 0948949 | Micha van den Herik
  • 0939318 | Tim van Leuveren
  • 0855969 | Job van der Velde
  • 0941574 | Floris van der Velden

Week 1


Delays with the trains are a common complaint of most people, and the company Dutch Railways (‘Nederlandse Spoorwegen’) takes a lot of the blame. Some of the delays are caused by small objects positioned on the tracks or the condition of the railway tracks by itself. As a result, the train’s stopping distance increases by big margin. For this problem, a small robot is designed to minimize these problems. It will check the tracks for snow and leaves and use laser technology to free the tracks of these things. Not only that, it also detects the wear and will ultimately also maintain the condition of the tracks.

USE Aspects

User: NS

Could be an expert knowing all the in’s and out’s of the machine. But in general, it is the NS themselves. Efficiency is important for the User. The machine will need to have the ability to move at the same speed as standard NS trains and be able to remove obstacles, leaves and snow when needed, as well as detect any wear on tracks and railway switches. The machine should not conflict to much with the current situation. The Netherlands already has one of the most tight packed schedules in the world, with single delays often causing a chain of delays. The machine should work between (or outside) this schedule, else it will not have any benefit. The main purpose of the machine is to prevent delays and when it is not able to fit in the current schedule, it will only cause more delays. The machine should be easily operable. However, since not everyone has to use this machine, easily operable is not high on the priority list.

Society: Train travelers

Delays can occur due to many reasons, for example tracks that are in need of reparation, or bad weather conditions. Train travelers want to get from point A to B as quickly as possible, delays don't add to the train traveling experience. By the use of an automation machine, which can detect and remove obstacles that cause delays, train travelers can get from A to B more quickly. Time always translates to money, and for all three USE aspects money is on the priority list.

Enterprise: ProRail

As mentioned in User, efficiency is important for both the User and Enterprise. The enterprise is also held partly responsible for the delays and thus they would like to prevent them as much as possible. Also, the Enterprise want the machine to be most profitable as possible. The cost of the machine is then also desired to be as low as possible, while still doing its tasks. It should be reliable because failure can lead to even larger delays or train accidents, which in turn lead to larger costs. It has to be cheaper than the ways used currently or it should weigh up to the costs of the delays, else it is not profitable investing in it. Most of the arguments mentioned in User and Enterprise will overlap. In our case, we will be more focusing on the Entrepreneurial side of ProRail.

Our focus

Our main focus for this project is on the Enterprise, ProRail, and a little bit on the User, NS, since these two have quite some things in common. To us, the most important aspects are efficiency, reliability and costs of the machine and these aspects go best with the Enterprise. We would like the machine to be reliable and efficient, while keeping the costs as low as possible. Our focus lies here because there are already some systems that are able to do (part) of the jobs we want to achieve. But we would like to combine them and make them better. And for our product to be of any interest to the Enterprise, the costs must be low. At least lower than what is currently spent on these activities. But we will not only focus on production costs, also, the maybe a bit more transparent, indirect costs of the machine. Like for example when the machine is broken and thus non-operable, it will cost money. If the machine is slow, it will cost money. These 'costs' are taken into account under the aspects reliability and efficiency respectively.


  • Functions at the same time as other trains are in use (same speed as the trains)
  • Detection wear of tracks
    • Rust
    • Cracks (ultrasonic?)
    • Dimensions & shape
  • Maintenance of tracks;
    • Removing snow, using a laser
    • Removing leaves, using a laser and compressed air/shovel
    • Removing rust, using a laser

Side Objectives

  • Not have much wear of itself on the tracks
  • Charge in front of the trains for optimal use
  • Modular ‘carts’ -> different equipment for different tasks
  • Additional detection: Condition of welds, fasteners, sleepers and ballast, temperature of railway
  • Possible detection of railway track geometry using gyroscope. (heavy maintenance required for readjusting railway track geometry)


  • Good for the climate and environment.


  • The focus lies on the User and the Enterprise, which are the NS and ProRail, respectively. Especially the Enterprise aspects are important for this system. This means that the system needs to be efficient, sustainable and that the production costs need to be as low as possible while still remaining quality.
  • Research has to be carried out about state-of-the-art technology. For example, one of the recent developments in railway technology is a laser which can remove leaves from the railway tracks [1]. We will also implement this technique into our system. Also, currently a monitor has been developed to check the condition of the tracks [2]. This technique is used to measure the cross section without contact. This technique could possibly be used for our system.
  • A literature study will make clear if our idea is really innovative and unique. We will also do research about how the system needs to be designed, what the most efficient form is, how it needs to be loaded, etc.


  1. Smith, O. (2016). No more commuter misery? Trains fight leaves with lasers. Retrieved from http://www.thememo.com/2016/09/12/train-leaves-leaf-zapping-trains-rail-safety-and-standards-board-are-arming-up-with-microwaves-and-lasers/
  2. ETS SPOOR B.V. (n.d.). Railmonitor. Retrieved from http://www.etsspoor.nl/producten/meetapparatuur/railmonitor/

Railway Innovation. (2016). Protran and Johns Hopkins University develop unmanned rail inspection robot. Retrieved from http://railwayinnovation.com/protran-and-johns-hopkins-university-develop-unmanned-rail-inspection-robot/

Loccioni Group. (2012). Felix, robot for railroad switch dimensional measurement. Retrieved from http://research.loccioni.com/en/robotics/felix/

IF design. (2016). Railroad Probe. Retrieved from http://ifworlddesignguide.com/entry/90335-railroad-probe/

Week 2


The above link guides you to our Gantt chart, which has been made with the help of the program "Microsoft Project". We have divided our plan into research, prototype and requirements, and deliverables. First, we’ve described the milestones and the date on which they have to be accomplished. After that, we’ve split up these milestones into different tasks and allocated people to these different tasks, as can be seen in our Gantt chart.

Laser Leaves, Rust and Snow Removal

One of the aspects of the railway robot is to perform maintenance on the tracks. The focus herein lies with removing rust, snow and leaves. All of these tasks are possible with state of the art lasers. According to Oliver Smith [1] leaves on railway tracks alone are cause for 5800 hours of delay per year for the British National Rail. A special microwave ray has already been found to be effective in removing wet leaves from the tracks, but further research on using lasers for this purpose is still being conducted and is estimated to be even better.

In the car industry a handheld 1000-watt rust removal laser is already available [2]. This laser is able to remove rust, dirt, coatings and paint in mere seconds. The laser works by adding its energy to the dirt/rust layer, which evaporates, while the base material reflects most of this energy, thus remaining unaffected [3].


Ice and snow can also be removed by adding laser energy. The patent of Roger and Rose Vega describes an ice removal system for airplanes [4]. The laser vaporizes the ice by moving slowly over the covered surface, thereby re-exposing it.

These three different laser technologies could be combined for all three maintenance purposes since the basic principle for removing the unwanted substance is the same, after which it could be mounted on a railway robot.


There are many different causes for the disturbances in the Dutch railway system. From january 2011 until february 2017, 15110 disturbances were reported. Shown in Graph 1, the most common disturbances are accordingly [5]:

  1. Faulty train (2279 disturbances, 15,1%)
  2. Signal interference (1640 disturbances, 10,9%)
  3. Railway switch failure (1593 disturbances, 10,5%)
  4. Collision with a person (1498 disturbances, 9,9%)
  5. Repair work (691 disturbances, 4,6%)
  6. Previous disturbance (529 disturbances, 3,5%)
  7. Signal and handle failure (450 disturbances, 3%)
  8. Signal and railway switch failure (390 disturbances, 2,6%)
  9. Power outage (388 disturbances, 2,6%)
  10. Level crossing failure (320 disturbances, 2,1%)
  11. Miscellaneous (5346 disturbances, 35.3%)

The miscellaneous disturbances consist of both the weather and external factors, which consist of rare disturbances such as theft or vandalism of the copper in the railway tracks, people or animals close to the railway tracks or roadside fires [6]. Concerning the weather, it can have a big impact on the train schedule as the different seasons in the Netherlands all influence the schedule.

On the one hand, there is the turbulent weather in the fall and winter. Leaves are a well-known problem in this time of year. But actually, the main problem is not the leaves, but actually the smoothness of the railway track. The leaves and rain together results in a mush, which makes the tracks more slippery, which on its turn the grip of the train wheels decreases. As a result, the circular shape of the wheels changes and they need to be repaired. In addition, the stopping distance increases exponentially, which has to be accounted for [7]. Snow and ice, next to the slipperiness of the railway track, also cause the railway switches to freeze or get blocked by the snow and ice.

Not only the cold, also hot temperatures can have impact on the railway tracks. Due to the increase in temperature, the steel stretches which causes the tracks to bend. The railways are then unusable to be driven over by a train.

With the railway maintenance robots, the disturbances concerning the railway switches, the weather and a part of the repair work are planned to be solved. These three different disturbances cover a notable part of the total disturbances in the Dutch railway system. Assuming a high efficiency, the railway maintenance robots could potentially prevent a great part of these disturbances, resulting in thousands less disturbances over the researched period.

Detection geometry

A problem with the railway can also be that is shifts in the cobblestones on which the track is placed. The track can be shifted into the cobblestones, resulting in a height difference between the two tracks. Currently, to detect whether or not the railway has shifted, is detected by a railway constructors themselves when checking the normal maintenance planning. This can be done quicker and more efficiently than what the current plan of action. With the use of a gyroscope inside of the monitor machine, the angle of the train can be measured. Also with the help of a device which measures velocity, the position of the vehicle along the track can be determined with an analog to digital converter. Moreover, a whole digital implementation can be made of the track (and if done accordingly, compared to what the original geometry of the tracks has to be. This process can save time, since it is all done digitally instead with the use of humans on only small portions of the track. The vehicle which will detect the geometry can move at higher speeds, and process the data immediately. Comparing the processed date digitally will also make the comparison more accurate than what humans can make of certain parts of railway tracks. [8]

Detection wear

An improvement of what the can be digitally implemented of the geometry of the total railway, the same type of measurement can be used to measure the wear and profile of the railway. The old method involved physical contact with the railway and was only able to measure the geometry and undulation of the railway (should a certain threshold be achieved, maintenance workers will have a closer look on the railway). With the new laser method these same parameters, as well as more important ones such as wear and profile of the railway, can be measured. The new innovative approach used, is based on image analysis and processing to reconstruct the whole track profile digitally (just like the geometry measurement). The railways reflects light back into cameras which can detect lasers and can internally process this data. The data will then be converted to a 3D projected image of the track. Using this technique, no extra wear will be made to the railway while measuring the wear. Moreover, the measurements can be done more quickly, since all the data is processed while the vehicle is moving over the track. Using a high-performance architecture, a big amount of information can be processed in a smart and fast method, since it is not possible to constantly store all the images and process them offline (for example with the use of pipelining and parallelism). Also, the use of high-level image analysis avoids the need for continuous and accurate alignment of the monitoring system with the track. The image processing method can be designed in such a way, that it can self-align itself (for example with the combination of the gyroscope as mentioned above). [9]

Drone Tests

ProRail is testing unmanned helicopters to check the heating of the railway switches.[10][11] This technique is especially useful during wintertime because these switches causes many disturbances during wintertime. The switches can freeze and can become clogged. To prevent the railway switches to freeze and become clogged there is a heating system built into the switches which can heat the switch when the temperatures drop below zero degrees Celsius. However this system does not always work and this problem is hard to detect in time. So ProRail came up with a solution; unmanned helicopters equipped with an infrared camera. This camera can detect whether the heating system is operating or not.


In this picture you see a picture where the heating system is working properly. The infrared images provide ProRail with information over the switches and ProRail can act accordingly. So the reason why we do not take this problem into account is that this is already a good solution. And our railway maintenance robot operates at the railway itself so it is hard to detect whether or not the switcher are working. This maintenance robot will focus on detecting the wear of the railway and cleaning the railway from snow and leaves.

Railway monitor

To detect the wear of the railways the railway monitor will be implemented on the railway maintenance robot. The railway monitor is a mobile measuring system which can measure the cross direction profile of the railway tracks. [12] This system uses a laser for the measurements and stores these measurements internally. Some special software will then compare the measurements with the references for cross direction profile and draw conclusions accordingly. The results are also shown immediately on a screen on the device itself. For the implementation of this system on the railway maintenance robot some features will be improved. Such as the communication of the measurement result immediately to the headquarters instead of storing it in the device itself. Also the screen will be unneeded.


Felix is the first mobile robot for inspecting railway switches.[13] This robot is equipped with profilometers which create a 3D reconstruction of the inspected switch. This is a useful robot to increase the reliability of the railway switches but can only be used for inspecting these switches. The railway maintenance robot can do this either and can be deployed for other tasks such as cleaning the railway. It can also inspect the railway itself along with the railway switches.

Current Costs

It is hard to determine the exact cost of the trouble caused by weather conditions, because total amounts spent on maintenance are given but specific amounts, like the ‘cost’ of snow, is not to be found anywhere. Also, these costs are hard to estimate. These costs are not linear compared to the occurrences, meaning each disturbance costs the same amount of money. The total maintenance costs can be found in the year overview of ProRail, and because ProRail is under partial supervision of the Dutch government, their year overview is public and can be found on their website. The year overview for 2016 has not been published yet, so all data used is from 2015 [14]. In 2015, ProRail received €1.098 million to spend on maintenance and management of tracks, this is a little bit more compared to 2014. They spent €950 million. From this money, ProRail spent €139 million on large-scale maintenance and €269 million on small-scale maintenance. Large-scale maintenance is the maintenance needed to ensure reliability and quality in the medium-long to long term. This includes for example polishing the tracks or preparing the tracks for the winter season. Small-scale maintenance includes all the maintenance needed to ensure availability and safety, as well as incidental maintenance. This is more short-term maintenance. Examples of these are inspections or replacing of (small) components. ProRail also spent €154 million on managements. Their year overview states this was largely used on ICT services, of which some are used to detect problems in advance. To us, the large-scale maintenance costs are of most use, since they cover the weather conditions. The management costs could be of some use but are not our priority. When our machine can detect problems on rails in advance, some ICT systems will not be needed anymore. This can be a huge cost saver, because in 2015, ProRail invested €60 million these ICT systems to prevent disturbances.

Week 3

Week 4

Week 5

Week 6

Week 7

Week 8


[1] Smith, O. (2016). No more commuter misery? Trains fight leaves with lasers. Retrieved from The Memo

[2] Sorokanich, B. (2016). This Hand-Held Laser Makes Rust Literally Evaporate. Retrieved from Road and Track

[3] P-Laser (2017). Laser cleaning applications. Retrieved from P-Laser

[4] Vega, R. et all (1990). Laser ice removal system. Retrieved from Google Patents

[5] Statistics about railway disturbances in the Netherlands. Retrieved from Rijdende Treinen

[6] Different kind of disturbances around railway tracks. Retrieved from: ProRail

[7] Article about leavs on the railway tracks. Retrieved from : Metronieuws

[8] Paper geometry railways. Retrieved from: [1]

[9] Paper wear railways. Retriever from: [2]

[10] Drones with infrared cameras 1. Retrieved from: ProRail

[11] Drones with infrared cameras 2. Retrieved from: Tweakers

[12] Railway monitor. Retrieved from: ETS Spoor

[13] Railway switches inspection robot Felix. Retrieved from: Loccioni

[14] Jaarverslag 2015, ProRail. Retrieved from: ProRail